Should the DSM-IV or DSM-5 list abused substances?

There are a number of substances that come naturally to mind when one thinks about substance abuse or addiction. Bath Salts, Super Glue, the propellant from canned whipped cream, and prescription drugs are all examples of substances that a person could abuse or become addicted to. Individuals engaging in this type of behavior may have a difficult time distinguishing between a “good” drug such as penicillin, and a “harmful” drug such as alcohol. Because of this, many times when professionals attempt to assist someone with a drug-taking behavior, they are faced with an uphill battle regarding perception.


History has also shown us that over time, various types of substances have gone through periods of acceptance versus non-acceptance based upon community standards. Even the way that a substance is being consumed has influenced society’s opinion regarding the level of acceptability of a drug. Opium as a drug could be utilized in a variety of ways, including drinking a liquid form and smoking the substance. “The respectable way was to drink it, usually in a liquid form called laudanum. By contrast, the smoking of opium, as introduced by Chinese immigrants imported for manual labor in the American West, was considered degrading and immoral (Levinthal, 11). Over time, American society came to see that opium was a very dangerous drug, regardless of how it was consumed.

I believe that the American Psychiatric Association’s (APA) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) accurately does not list any specific substances in order to guide professionals treating substance abuse. By not listing specific substances, the actual substance becomes irrelevant. “The position of the American Psychiatric Association is that a judgment of whether a person has a problem of dependence or abuse should depend on the behavior of that person, not on the chemical that is being consumed” (Levinthal, 42).

By not listing specific substances, the APA accomplishes a number of things. First, the temptation to argue over whether or not a substance is “bad” for an individual is removed. A professional does not have to waste valuable time convincing someone that canned whipped cream is a bad thing. The substance is irrelevant in the clinical setting, only the behavior of the person in treatment does. Second, the APA does not have to worry about the changing of societal norms. The use of many drugs including opium and cocaine have been accepted by society in the past. However, as doctors learned more about the dangers of these substances, the acceptability of them has waned. By not listing substances at all, the DSM becomes a more timeless resource that does not need to be updated to include nor exclude specific substances based on sometimes arbitrary attitudes.

In using this approach, the professional can focus on treating behaviors and utilize the increase or mitigation of the destructive fallout of the behavior as a way to mark progress in the person being treated. It’s really hard to convince someone to stop doing something that feels really good unless you can show them how the behaviors they are exhibiting while feeling good are worse for them than the feeling the substance induces.

Maggie Morona

Levinthal, C. F. (2012). Drugs, behavior, and modern society. (6th ed.). Boston: Pearson College Div.


About Maggie Morona

Maggie is the author of original content and the curator of linked content at Psyntax. She is an undergraduate student at Florida Tech. While studying Applied Psychology, she began to see how handy understanding Psychology could be when working with Social Media, and began sharing content linking the two together. She has been blogging for 2 years, and also works as a website and social media evaluator.

Posted on May 28, 2013, in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink. 1 Comment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Black America Web

Entertainment, News and Lifestyle for African Americans

The Little Lifestyle Blog

Cruelty Free Beauty, Lifestyle, Fashion, Health


a whole lot of thoughts, feelings and ideas

The Neighborhood

The Story within the Story


A great site

The Oatmeal - Comics, Quizzes, & Stories

In Social Media, its all about the Context of the Content

Saf Ali's Blog

Blogging about society, culture, race, religion, identity... and even tech stuff.


Prattle from author Lucy Blue


social marketing blog

Social Media News, Technology and Marketing Tips


There are no antibiotics for sarcastic inflections


Beauty - Hauls - Reviews - Youtube


This site is the cat’s pajamas

Gotta Find a Home

Conversations with Street People

The Seeker's Dungeon

Troubling the Surf with the Ocean


Just another site


Connecting the world to Truth, so that Justice can be served


In Social Media, its all about the Context of the Content

%d bloggers like this: